Alice is Pastor Tim's wife and the mother of Claire Louise. Pastor Tim shared with his wife Paige's revelation that her parents are Russian spies, causing a rift in Pastor Tim and Paige's relationship.

According to Paige, Alice frequently gossips about church members. When her husband disappeared during a trip to Ethiopia, Alice threatened to expose the Jennings as KGB spies. When Pastor Tim was found, Alice asked Paige to tell her parents she was sorry. ("Munchkins") She later gives birth to a daughter, Claire Louise.